The housing market has been challenging for both buyers and sellers over the past few years, but there’s finally a glimmer of hope on the horizon. More homes are hitting the market as some homeowners with ultra-low mortgage rates are beginning to make the difficult decision to sell.
A Market in Transition
Recent data from Realtor.com shows promising movement in housing inventory. In April, 20 of the 50 largest U.S. metropolitan areas saw their inventory levels exceed pre-pandemic norms, up from 18 metros in March. This gradual increase suggests that the severe housing shortage that has plagued the market may be slowly starting to ease.
However, don’t expect this trend to accelerate dramatically anytime soon. The so-called “mortgage lock-in effect” continues to keep many potential sellers firmly planted in their current homes.
The Numbers Tell the Story
The scale of the mortgage lock-in phenomenon is striking. According to Cotality, an industry data provider, more than half of all mortgages in every single state carry interest rates below 4%. The concentration is even more pronounced in certain regions:
This creates a stark contrast with recent mortgage activity. Most homeowners who secured new mortgages in recent years are paying rates above 6%, and the 30-year mortgage average hasn’t dropped below 6% since 2022, according to Freddie Mac data.
The Regional Reality
Molly Boesel, principal economist at Cotality, points out an interesting pattern: states that have seen more mortgage originations over the past three years tend to have higher concentrations of loans with rates at 6% or above. This geographic distribution helps explain why some markets are seeing more inventory relief than others.
What This Means for the Market
The mortgage rate divide creates a complex dynamic in today’s housing market. Homeowners with those coveted sub-4% rates are essentially receiving a significant monthly subsidy compared to what they would pay if they moved and took out a new mortgage at current rates. For many, the financial penalty of giving up their low rate simply outweighs their desire or need to relocate.
Meanwhile, potential homebuyers and current homeowners looking to refinance remain in a holding pattern, hoping for any opportunity to reduce their monthly housing costs.
Learn how our local real estate agent, independent broker approach pairs you with a highly invested local expert backed by the best support system in the industry
Looking Ahead
Unfortunately for those waiting for relief, mortgage rates aren’t expected to fall significantly this year, and home prices continue their upward trajectory. This means the lock-in effect will likely persist, though we may see gradual improvements in inventory as life circumstances force some homeowners to sell despite the rate penalty.
The housing market remains in a delicate balancing act, with inventory slowly improving but affordability challenges persisting. For now, the modest uptick in listings provides at least some hope for buyers who have been competing for limited options, even if the broader mortgage lock-in effect continues to shape market dynamics across the country.
To read more, visit Mapping mortgage rates by state: Where homeowners feel locked in.
