The real estate investing world loves to shout “Put everything in an LLC!” as if it’s universal wisdom. Meanwhile, seasoned investors often do the opposite, holding multiple properties in their personal name or lumping 10+ properties into a single LLC. The truth? Both extremes can be wrong, and the right answer depends entirely on your specific situation.
Get a Free Virtual Rental Evaluation Plus a Custom Cost Quote
Let’s cut through the noise and talk about what actually matters.
Understanding What You’re Really Getting (and Giving Up)
The Personal Ownership Approach
What you gain:
What you risk:
Real-world context: For a single rental with $50K equity, adequate insurance, and a well-screened tenant, the actual risk is often quite low. The $800-2,000 annual cost of LLC maintenance and tax prep could be better spent on a $2M umbrella policy.
The Single LLC Approach
What you gain:
What you risk:
Real-world context: This is the “better than nothing” approach that many investors fall into. It provides some protection, but if you have significant equity across multiple properties, you’re still exposing everything in the LLC to a single liability event.
The Multiple LLC Strategy
What you gain:
What you risk:
Real-world context: This is the gold standard for significant portfolios, but it’s overkill when you’re just getting started. The crossover point is when the combined equity and risk profile justify the $3,000-10,000+ annual overhead.
The Insurance Reality Check
Here’s what rarely gets discussed: proper insurance often provides better practical protection than an LLC for typical rental property risks.
A landlord policy with $1-2M in liability coverage plus a $2M personal umbrella policy costs roughly $1,500-3,000 annually and protects you against the vast majority of rental property risks: slip and falls, dog bites, minor property damage, normal tenant disputes.
LLCs protect against the scenarios insurance doesn’t: environmental contamination, massive structural failures, catastrophic incidents, or situations where insurance denies your claim. These are lower probability but higher consequence events.
The smart play? Insurance PLUS entity structure, not one or the other. But when you’re deciding how elaborate your LLC structure needs to be, factor in that good insurance is already handling 90% of your risk scenarios.
The Practical Decision Framework
Start Here: The Single Property Analysis
Keep it in your personal name if:
Move it to an LLC if:
The Growing Portfolio: 2-5 Properties
Single LLC works when:
Consider separate LLCs when:
The Serious Investor: 6+ Properties
At this stage, you need a real strategy:
For 6-10 properties: Consider a tiered approach with 2-3 LLCs, grouping properties by value, risk profile, or geography. Put your highest value properties in separate LLCs, and group lower value properties together.
For 10+ properties: You need multiple LLCs, possibly with a holding company structure. The annual costs are now a legitimate business expense proportional to the assets at risk. Consider working with a real estate attorney to design a structure that makes sense for your specific portfolio.
The Rules That Actually Matter
Rule 1: Insurance first, structure second. Don’t put a single property in an LLC and think you’re protected. Get proper insurance regardless of entity structure.
Rule 2: If you can’t afford to maintain the LLC properly, don’t create it. A poorly maintained LLC is worse than no LLC—you get the costs without the protection. This means separate bank accounts, no commingling, proper meeting minutes, and arm’s length transactions.
Rule 3: Don’t let entity structure stop you from buying properties. Many new investors obsess over LLCs before they own anything. Buy the first property in your name with great insurance, then restructure later when it makes sense.
Rule 4: Equity is the key metric, not quantity. Two properties with $500K equity each need more protection than five properties with $50K equity each.
Rule 5: Reassess every 2-3 years. As equity grows, as your portfolio expands, as your personal wealth increases—what made sense three years ago might not make sense today.
Rule 6: One LLC for 10+ properties is lazy risk management. If you’ve built significant wealth in real estate, protect it properly. The cost of multiple entities is a rounding error compared to losing everything in one lawsuit.
Rule 7: State matters. LLC costs, protections, and tax implications vary significantly by state. Wyoming and Delaware are popular for good reason, but managing out-of-state entities adds complexity.
Rule 8: Don’t cheap out on formation or maintenance. DIY LLCs often have gaps in protection. If you’re going to create an entity structure, pay for proper legal setup and annual compliance.
The Decision Matrix
Here’s a simple framework to pressure-test your situation:
Calculate your exposure:
Calculate your protection:
Calculate the gap: If your maximum uninsured exposure is more than 20% of your total net worth, you need better entity structure. If it’s less than 10%, your current insurance may be sufficient.
Factor in costs:
If LLC costs exceed 3% of annual rental profit and your gap is small, you’re over-engineering.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
The “I’ll fix it later” trap: Transferring property from personal name to LLC later often triggers due-on-sale clauses, reassessment for property taxes, or title issues. It’s doable but messy.
The commingling disaster: Using your LLC account to pay personal expenses, or vice versa, can void your liability protection entirely. Maintain pristine separation.
The forgot-to-file failure: Missing annual reports, letting your LLC dissolve, or failing to maintain good standing negates all your protection. Set calendar reminders.
The too-clever-by-half structure: Complex multi-tier holding company structures might look sophisticated, but if you can’t maintain them properly or explain them to a judge, they’re worthless.
Property Management Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
The Bottom Line
The LLC question isn’t “yes or no”—it’s “how much and when?”
For your first rental, focus on great insurance and building equity. For properties 2-5, a single LLC is usually the sweet spot. Beyond that, you need a thoughtful strategy that scales with your portfolio value.
The goal isn’t to create the perfect liability shield—it’s to have reasonable protection that you can actually maintain while still growing your business. Complexity is expensive, both in dollars and mental overhead.
Protect yourself intelligently, but don’t let entity structure paralysis stop you from building wealth in real estate. Get good insurance, create entity structure that matches your risk profile, and focus most of your energy on the things that actually matter: finding good deals, managing properties well, and building long-term wealth.
And remember: the people shouting “always use an LLC!” often have something to sell you. The people with 10 properties in their personal name often got lucky that nothing bad happened. Be smarter than both.
