The Growing Popularity of York County’s Hotspots
Rock Hill and Fort Mill have become some of South Carolina’s most sought-after destinations in recent years. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, Fort Mill ranked 13th nationally in growth among municipalities with populations over 20,000. Rock Hill isn’t far behind, continuing to attract newcomers drawn to the area’s unique blend of small-town charm and proximity to Charlotte’s metropolitan amenities.
With this population boom, one might expect a thriving rental market offering plenty of options for newcomers wanting to test the waters before committing to a home purchase. After all, relocating from out of state is a significant undertaking, and many prefer to rent initially while exploring neighborhoods and determining which area feels most like “home.”
Yet a quick search on popular real estate platforms reveals a surprising scarcity of single-family homes available for rent in both Rock Hill and Fort Mill. This shortage leaves many newcomers wondering: why are rental homes so difficult to find in such popular, growing communities?
The Hidden Tax Burden Behind South Carolina’s Rental Shortage
The answer lies in South Carolina’s property tax structure, which creates a significant financial disincentive for homeowners considering converting their properties into rentals.
In South Carolina, homes are taxed in two distinct categories:
This difference might seem modest at first glance, but the impact doesn’t stop there. Investment properties also face substantially higher millage rates, creating a compounding effect that dramatically increases the tax burden.
The Real Numbers: A York County Example
To illustrate this impact, let’s consider a scenario with a $500,000 home in the Fort Mill area:
As a Primary Residence:
- $500,000 × 0.04 = $20,000 (assessed value)
- $20,000 × 0.2375 (millage rate) = $4,750 annual property tax
As a Rental Property:
- $500,000 × 0.06 = $30,000 (assessed value)
- $30,000 × 0.533 (investment property millage) = $15,990 annual property tax
The difference is staggering: $11,240 per year in additional taxes for the exact same property once it transitions from owner-occupied to rental status. Pretty brutal for a so called laissez-faire state. If we sell the state to gambling companies as so many have maybe we can offset this tax with that revenue.
For homeowners considering keeping their property as a rental when moving to a new home, this means they would need to charge an additional $937 per month just to cover the increased tax burden—before accounting for any other expenses, maintenance, or profit margin.
The Rock Hill Situation
Rock Hill faces similar challenges. While the specific millage rates differ slightly from Fort Mill, the fundamental tax structure remains the same. Property owners in Rock Hill who convert their homes to rentals face the same 4% to 6% assessment rate increase, plus higher millage rates for investment properties.
Even with Rock Hill’s strong rental demand due to Winthrop University and growing business sectors, many homeowners find that the tax implications make converting to a rental financially unattractive compared to selling outright.
The Ripple Effect on Local Housing
This tax structure creates a cascading effect on the local housing market:
For young professionals relocating to work in Charlotte or local companies, families moving from out of state, or retirees looking to test the Carolina lifestyle, this rental shortage removes the “try before you buy” option that many prefer when relocating.
Potential Solutions
Some property owners work with professional property management companies that can help maximize rental income and efficiency to offset some of the tax burden. Others explore forming LLCs or other business structures that might provide some tax advantages, though these approaches come with their own complexities.
At the policy level, some community advocates have suggested that York County and South Carolina lawmakers should consider tax reforms that wouldn’t penalize rental properties so severely, potentially helping to expand rental housing options in high-demand areas like Rock Hill and Fort Mill.
Ready to Get Your Rental on the MoveZen System?
Our ultimate goal is to maximize your bottom line income while minimizing headaches. This starts with our new owner onboard process
Thinking of Switching Property Management Companies?
Don’t let the unpleasant task of working with your current manager to close out your account hold you back, we’ll do it all. Just notify them once in writing, and we’ll do the rest
The Bottom Line for Property Owners
If you own a home in Rock Hill or Fort Mill and are considering converting it to a rental property, be sure to:
For many homeowners, once they crunch the numbers, selling often emerges as the more financially sound option—which continues to contribute to the rental housing shortage throughout York County’s most desirable communities.
Until South Carolina’s property tax approach changes, Rock Hill and Fort Mill will likely continue to see robust home sales but limited rental inventory, creating ongoing challenges for newcomers hoping to rent before making a more permanent commitment to these otherwise welcoming communities.
